|
Chapter 3
Running a Business in Costa Rica
Quick Index (you may jump directly to the section below)
Business Structures
Buying a Business
Labor Regulations
Minimum Wages
Professional Resources
Ahh, so now you have arrived in paradise, but......
Let me tell you a little story about myself, and I think you may
find that you relate to it.
For the first 2 years or so that I was here, I did almost nothing
constructive. I had purchased a computer and had dial up internet
access, which was all that was available in those days, but it didn't work
very well. Still, I was able to get my "internet fix" every day.
So, between the internet, computer, and the local bars and restaurants,
I was occupying most of my time and was not bored. I was, what you
might call, semi retired, though at a very young age of 38 and 39.
But, as time went on, I found that partying 5 days a week and fooling
around on my computer and the internet was starting to get old and boring.
Many people look forward to that glorious retirement they have always dreamed
of, but, many also find that after a year or so of relaxing, they need
something to keep them occupied, so either look for a job or small business
to start.
Others come here with the intent to start a business from the beginning.
And still others come here thinking that they are going to get a
regular job here. Well, that route is not easy at all, and is almost
impossible for the regular person. The only exceptions have been
teaching English or working in a sportsbook or call center under the table.
However, the new immigration law comes into force this coming August, and
at that time there will be new sanctions both on the illegal worker and
their employer, which means this practice will quickly disappear.
But, there are still alternatives.
For example, you can form a Costa Rican corporation [most often this
is the SA, or sociedad anomina type], and the corporation can take on contract
work. They can appoint you to fulfill the contract on behalf of the
SA, and then the "employer" pays the SA and you can withdraw your money
from the SA.
We represent a very competent local law firm and consulting business
that can meet most of your legal, residency, and relocation needs.
It also provides business consulting and services that you may find useful.
We will tell you more about this in this chapter as well as the appropriate
chapters on residency and other matters.
Business Structures
The types of business structures in Costa Rica are pretty much like
those you are familiar with: sole proprietorships, partnerships, and corporations
[SA's are the most common form, and work much like the regular corporations
back home]. Of these forms, for an expat doing business here, the
SA is almost the only choice. If you have a "partner," you simply
give him or her whatever percentage of the stock you agree to. The
corporate structure limits your liability, and is really the only totally
legal and clean way most foreigners can start and run a business here.
In case you are not aware of it already, the Costa Rican bureaucracy
can be a real head ache for you. The best alternative is to hire
a professional and reliable local law firm to handle these matters for
you. The process may still take 6 months or longer, depending on
the type of business you are starting. The most difficult would probably
be a bar that wishes to have the recognition of the ICT, or the Tourism
Institute.
If you business is dealing with tourists, you will no doubt want
to get ICT recognition anyway, as it gives you advantages over not having
the status. One of the main benefits is that this status gives you
a level playing field across the country, whereas without this status you
are subject to the whims of the local municipality in your area.
One word about the above: a non ICT recognized local business
will have to apply to their local municipality for final licensing.
This can either be a breeze or it can be very bad, depending n the municipality
you plan to locate in.
Some municipalities have an anti gringo outlook [this seems to be
the case in Alajuela, for instance, according to some reports that we have
seen]. On the other hand, others will roll out the welcome mat for
you and even provide some advice and assistance. It has been reported
to us that two of the best in this regard in the Central Valley are Escazu
and Santa Ana.
Another option, which may soon be closing, is to open your business
in a free trade zone if it is suitable for that. Import/export operations,
call centers, etc., have all benefited form locating in these zones, because
the local municipality does not come into play, and you operate under a
totally different and more flexible set of rules. Unfortunately,
these zones may soon expire unless they are renewed by the next government.
But it is no accident that some of the largest "business parks" and multinational
corporations operate from these special areas.
So, LOCATION as well as ICT status can every bit as important as
what you are doing and the legal structure of the business, depending on
the type of business..
One final word of caution, be very careful if trying to locate a
business in the Maritime Zone right on the beach. For years, this
law has not been properly enforced, but, lately, here has been a drive
to enforce it, which has been a rude awakening to some long established
beach businesses, some of which have been bulldozed to the ground after
sometimes decades of operation. So, if you are locating in this zone
or especially buying an existing business in this area, WATCH OUT!
Again, competent and honest legal advice can save you a WHALE of a lot
of hurt and misery down the road. NOT getting GOOD legal advice is
perhaps the worst "money saving" mistake you could ever make!
See our chapter on Government and Law for more details on corporate
structure and other legal matters.
Buying a Business
One option many expats take is to buy an existing business from someone
else.
Theoretically, this option can save you lots of time and trouble,
meaning you can skip most of the onerous start up procedures and hurdles
and go directly to the starting gate.
While this is a definite advantage over starting a business from
scratch, the downside of this is that you can be taken to the cleaners
by an unscrupulous seller who is trying to dump their problems on you.
The possible problems are many, which may include unpaid back wages to
employees, loss of a license or lease, or other legal problems that may
not be readily apparent.
The best thing to do is to have a good lawyer check into the legal
status of the proposed purchase, digging real deep into potential problem
areas. He can then tell you whether he thinks the business has a
clean bill of health or not. You will also need to have a good accountant
do a THOROUGH inspection of the books and records, and perhaps even conduct
a complete audit to make sure all taxes, wages, social security payments,
etc. are current. Any one of these items could be a REAL EXPENSIVE
problem for you if no detected before you buy the business, so to get the
best experts n your side is the best investment you could possibly make.
Labor
Unless your business is going to be a one man or one woman enterprise,
you will need to hire employees. Be very careful in this area, because
the labor laws are pretty strict, and there are minimum salaries depending
on the type of work. Ignoring these regulations can be very expensive
for you if you get caught in violation.
The 3 basic legal principles that determine the existence of an employment
relationship under Costa Rican labor law are established in the Labor Code,
as follows:
1. Section 2: “Employer is any person or corporate entity,
private of public, that employs the services of another or of others, based
on an express or implied labor contract, written or verbal, individual
or joint.”
2. Section 4: “Employee is any person that gives another person
or entity his material, intellectual or material/intellectual services,
based on an express or implied labor contract, written or verbal, individual
or joint.”
3. Section 18: “Individual labor contract, whatever it is actually
called, is any contract, written or oral, in which a person commits to
give another person or entity his services or to undertake a piece of work,
under permanent dependency, and immediate or delegated direction of such
other entity or person in exchange for a payment of any kind or form.”
From these legal foundations, local case law is unanimous in stating
that there are three basic elements in a labor relationship, whose presence
is crucial to determine if the link between the parties is of the labor
kind, thus subject to all stipulations and protections of the Labor Code
or of a non labor kind, solely governed by ordinary and non protectionist
civil regulations.
Such basic elements are that the service must be given personally;
that such service must be paid for and that it must be given under subordination
with respect to the employer. Of these three criteria, subordination
is considered as the main and essential element for the determination of
the presence or not of an employment type relationship since the other
two may be present and yet not necessarily involve the application of labor
law.
PERSONAL SERVICE
A contractual relationship cannot be considered as of the labor type,
if the service is not provided personally, which is essential to labor
relationships and basically means that what has been contracted can only
be performed by a sole individual, who cannot be substituted.
In a labor relationship, the party receiving the services is not
only interested in the provision of the services per se, but also on the
personal capacities of a specific individual. Local case law has
clearly stated that an important factor to rule out the existence of a
labor relationship is if it is detected that services are given by parties
other than the one signing the agreement.
Local Courts have even considered that once and if the possibility
of substitution is existent and has actually happened, it is not necessary
to determine if the other elements that create a labor relationship are
or are not present (mainly, as indicated, payment and subordination) since
the sole absence of the “personal service” element is considered sufficient
to rule out the application of labor law.
The above said does not mean that a labor relationship will be avoided
by solely indicating in the agreement between the parties that the services
can be performed by other individuals. Such fact must be confirmed
in the day to day reality of the services rendered and as such, services
must be performed by the contracting party or any other individual selected
by such for those purposes, if the replacement meets the criteria established
in the contract.
In order to establish the non-existence of this personal element
to avoid entering into a labor agreement, it is recommended to have a corporation
execute the agreement on behalf of the service provider, and for it to
issue locally authorized official invoices for the payment of the services.
For this mechanism to actually work, it will be optimal for the service
providing company executing the service contract to have several employees
and that as such they could be used to provide the services, following
the guidelines set up in the agreement.
PAYMENT
For the relationship to be considered as of labor type, the service
provider must have compensation for his work. Payment in an
employment relationship can be calculated by unit of time, by task or by
piece of work and made in currency, in currency and specie, or by participation
in earnings, sales or collections from the employer.
SUBORDINATION
As indicated above, this element is considered essential for the
existence of a labor relationship. It is defined as the condition
in which the employee's autonomy is limited, with regards to the provision
of the services, due to the written or oral agreement with the employer,
such limitation coming from the capacity of the employer to guide the employee's
activities.
Subordination is also considered as an actual dependency condition
created by the employer's right to direct and give orders, and the consequent
obligation by the employee of following such orders and directions and
submitting to the employer's will. For subordination to exist, it
is not enough to detect the possibility of giving orders, since the right
to give them and to replace at will the individual providing the services
is also considered to be needed by local Courts in order to confirm the
existence of this element.
Subordination includes the possibility by the employer to establish
disciplinary actions against the employee in cases of bad performance or
misbehavior, basically being capable of imposing direct orders and penalties
in case such orders are not followed. Evidently, this possibility
is many times in a gray area, since a non labor relationship must also
give the possibility to the contracting party to establish guidelines on
how the service will be provided. The key here would be to establish
such guidelines, but not a direct supervision and disciplinary regime for
the individuals providing the service.
The sole obligation to render reports on how the tasks have been
completed does not by itself creates a subordination regime, since it is
considered as an essential duty of information from one party to the other
which could be present in a non labor relationship as a performance obligation.
If, though, the performance of the services is controlled by the
service receiver with regards to the actual manner of undertaking of the
work activities -- such as, for example, establishing exact hours and days
of work as only one example -- and not only to their quality, the relationship
will be very probably considered as of labor type.
What is also accepted by the local labor laws as a non labor relationship
is when the party contracting the services, instead of directly controlling
how such services are rendered, is merely coordinating the activities.
In these cases of coordination, the link of the service provider
with the contracting company’s commercial activities does not consist of
a direct involvement on how the services are provided, but on the
indication of a specific “business program” in which the services are provided
as a means for the completion of such program. Coordination must
not infringe on the autonomy of the service provider with respect to the
choice of the specific means or forms used for performing the services.
With respect to schedules, it is considered that subordination exists
even if such schedules can be agreed upon by the parties at the outset
of the contract, but, once they have been set up, the service provider
cannot change them unilaterally and must comply with them as originally
agreed.
In general terms, there are elements that can be put in the contract
(and to be effective, to be present in the actual provision of the services
over time) to define the services as not being provided with subordination.
Such elements come into play if the service provider: (i) works on his
own; (ii) bears the risks associated with his activities; (iii) is liable
before the law for any illegal actions he may engage in while providing
the services; (iv) pays his own social security, taxes, etc.; (v) hires
his own employees, if any; (vi) works as an independent, for another employer
or employers; (vi) has the power of selecting a replacement for himself;
(vii) provides the services in a place or places not imposed by the service
receiver; (viii) does not get, from the service receiver, the instruments,
tools or materials he needs to perform the services.
Although the existence or non-existence of the following points
will not rule out or imply the existence, by themselves, of a labor relationship,
the following elements would be considered by a local Court of Law so as
to “suspect” the existence of such a relationship, and, as such, should
be avoided, if possible, and as many of them as also possible: (i) exclusivity
(as opposed to the possibility of providing services for other parties);
(ii) place of work under employer’s control; (iii) periodical and fixed
payment; (iv) submission to hourly shifts and schedules; (v) not having
the possibility to accept or reject provision of specific services; (vi)
provision by the employer to the employee of the material and personal
means needed for performing the services; (vii) registration before the
Costa Rican Social Security Agency and the length and continuity of the
service relationship.
WORK CONTRACT AND THE PRINCIPLE OF “REALITY CONTRACT”
Section 18 of the Costa Rican Labor Code, which has been already
referred to above, establishes the presumption of the existence of a contract
-written or oral- between the employer and the worker. The sole initiation
of the work relationship is sufficient for the presumption of the existence
of the contract and such agreement compels the two parties to obey the
obligations and rights established in the law.
Everything that is agreed upon by the parties of the labor relationship,
being agreed in writing or not, but existing as the current conditions
of the work relationship, becomes part of it. This corresponds to
a basic principle of local labor law (principle of “Contrato Realidad”
–Reality Contract in English –) which establishes that no matter what has
been agreed in writing as the contractual relationship employer-employee
or no matter what the prior contractual relationship contents were, what
rules is the current and real contents of the employment relationship,
even though they are different from the agreement, all in favor of the
employee (i.e. real work schedules vs. Contractually agreed work schedules;
actually paid salaries and compensations vs. contractually agreed compensation;
etc.).
While applying the “Reality Contract” principle to the labor relationships
vs. non-labor service agreements issue, we must bear in mind that under
local laws and case law, it is not important how the contract itself is
labeled by the parties, as it is constantly indicated by Labor Courts that
they consider that the employer frequently uses several mechanisms to avoid
the application of labor law, giving the contract the appearance of a non
labor matter.
At the end of the day, local Labor Courts will examine how the actual
relationship between the parties occurred, and in view of such and the
detection and evaluation of the elements that have been covered in the
paragraphs above, they will make the determination of its nature and the
applicable legal regime.
PRESUMPTION OF THE EXISTENCE OF A LABOR RELATIONSHIP
As per local laws and case law, the general rule is that the existence
of a labor relationship when services are provided is always presumed,
and the employer must bear the burden of proof of the contrary.
Notwithstanding the above, the general rule is reversed, as established
by case law, when services are not provided personally (but by a corporate
entity) and the parties expressly state, by the means of a written contract,
that the relationship is not of a labor nature. In this case, the
burden of proof is transferred to the service provider’s side, who must
demonstrate the existence of the elements that we have stated as determining
an employment relationship. In this type of situations, as indicated
by local case law, what is applied is a case by case examination of the
facts and proof in order to determine if the specific matter will be governed
by labor law.
LEGAL OBLIGATIONS BY THE EMPLOYER IF THE RELATIONSHIP IS CONSIDERED
A LABOR RELATIONSHIP
Although all measures possible to try to characterize the relationship
as out of the reach of local labor law are taken, the type of activities
that will be performed certainly pose a high risk of being considered by
a local Labor Court, if a dispute arises, as constituting a regular labor
relationship between the parties.
If that happens, it is important to have a clear picture of the
obligations that will materialize for the employer, which mainly consist
in penalties for the lack of registration of the employees before the local
Social Security Administration, as well as the payment of all labor related
compensations to which regular employees are entitled under Costa Rican
labor law, namely: vacations, Christmas bonus (also called thirteenth month),
right of notice of termination and severance pay.
Below are the details for each of the above:
Vacations
With regards to vacations, besides holidays and Sundays, the employee
is entitled to two weeks of paid vacation for each fifty weeks worked or,
in cases of contracts that terminate before such 50 weeks, a day for each
month worked. Vacations can be divided, but only in two segments.
Upon termination of the employment contract, unused vacation time
should be paid using as a base the average of salaries earned during the
last six months.
Christmas Bonus
Employees must be paid a bonus of one month’s salary after a year
of work (“aguinaldo”), or an amount proportionate to the time worked, if
it less than a year.
Right of notice of termination
After three months of employment, an employee has the right to receive
notice in the event of termination of employment without just cause by
the employer (if notice is not given, he must be paid one month's salary,
or a fraction if he has been employed for less than one year).
Severance payment
If the worker is fired without justification after at least three
months of service, the employer has to pay a severance payment whose amount
increases in accordance with the time served and could be up to twenty
two days per year worked, with a maximum calculated on the basis of eight
years, all according to a specific calculation table indicated by the Labor
Code.
Minimum Wages
Costa Rica closely controls salaries. While countries to the north
have minimum wages, Costa Rica has a separate minimum wage for nearly every
type of job. And the numbers keep changing, thanks to a continual devaluation
of the colon.
Every six months the government negotiates salary increases with
various employee unions. If the negotiations fail, as they do from time
to time, the president may issue a decree setting the new salaries in conjunction
with the Consejo Nacional de Salarios.
Under the latest decree that covers the first half of 2005, blue
collar workers in agriculture, tourism, manufacturing and a host of other
areas must earn from 3,903 to 5,377 colons daily, depending on qualifications.
That’s from $8.45 to $11.64. And that’s for a day.
Monthly, the legal minimums range from 117,014 colons a month for
someone like a janitor, a messenger or an elevator operator to 266,202
colons for a university master’s degree holder. That’s from $253 to $576
at the current exchange rate of about 462 colons to the U.S. dollar.
Some other salaries:
Domestic servant:
67,648 colons a month ($146) plus food.
University bachelor degree holder: 221,829 ($480).
Bartender:
4,475 colons a day ($9.69).
Bus driver:
4,475 colons a day ($9.69).
Tourist guide:
4,475 colons a day ($9.69).
Machine operator:
4,475 colons a day ($9.69).
Electrician or carpenter:
4,475 colons a day ($9.69).
Private accountant:
195,576 colons a month ($423).
Architectural draftsman:
136,409 colons ($295) a month.
Secretary:
136,409 colons ($295) a month.
General office worker:
126,973 colons a month ($275).
Gardener:
4,475 colons a day ($9.69)
The highest paid job title on the list is graduate journalist, which
pays 327,856 colons a month or $710.
A bare bones list of minimum salaries usually is available at news
outlets in the metropolitan area and legal bookstores. However, the Ministerio
de Trabajo y Seguridad Social has many more job classifications and specific
minimum salaries in its files.
Most professionals work for salaries established by their colegios
or trade organizations. For example, lawyers are supposed to get 10 percent
of the value of any contract they prepare.
Most companies try to pay around the legal minimum, although more
enlightened ones reward good employees. Although the salaries seem low
by North American standards, they are good for Latin America, and employees
here have the benefit of free medical care, pensions and other benefits
not fully reflected in the paycheck.
Professional Resources
If you are spending all of the money to either buy or start a business,
it is only wise to seek professional advice in all aspects of your purchase
or start up, which means seeking competent, professional advice in many
areas.
It is hard enough moving to an unfamilliar town or city in your native
country, but, in a foreign country where you may not even have a good command
of the local language, Spanish, it would be suicidal and foolish to proceed
on your own without such help. After all, if you find yourself on
the wrong side of some obscure regulation or another, you might have a
very costly fine or other penalty -- or, in a worse case scenerio, you
might lose your business altogether.
We have found from experience that the best idea is to have your own personal advisor(s) to "help show you the ropes." Whether you need legal, accounting, relocation, or just about any other type of service, Porongo, SA, is here to be your guide and at your service with professional assistance and recommendations based on our 11+ years here in this country. You can reach us by picking up the phone and calling our US phone number at: 408-834-8909. If no one answers, leave a message and the best time to call. Or, you can reach us via email at:
|